Back to insights

    Insights · 10 min

    How to compare SEO proposals and define meaningful monthly work

    Compare SEO proposals by the changes that will reach your website, the people responsible for implementing them and the evidence you will use to judge progress. A keyword count, article quota or monthly allocation of hours cannot tell you whether an engagement will produce more relevant enquiries. A useful proposal connects business priorities with specific pages, implementation, verification and the next decision. This guide is for a business owner or marketing lead choosing between agencies. It is not a universal pricing guide or a promise of rankings. The aim is to create a common brief, expose dependencies and agree on a monthly scope your organisation can actually deliver. The comparison framework below is NUMEDIA's editorial recommendation, rather than a certification scheme or a measured predictor of agency performance.

    Three proposal-shaped panels, with the centre panel highlighted in green.

    Start with the business you want to attract

    List three services or product groups you want to sell. For each, specify the target market, buyer and operational constraint. A manufacturer with a long sales cycle has different priorities from a local maintenance business with a small service area. A retailer with limited stock needs a different plan from one launching an additional category.

    Your brief should answer five questions: what do we sell, to whom, in which market, what makes an enquiry useful and who will support implementation? Include exclusions. Visits from outside a contractor's service area are not equivalent to relevant local enquiries. Content for hobbyists may generate traffic without helping a supplier that only sells to businesses.

    Give every shortlisted agency the same brief. Asking one for end-to-end delivery and another for advisory support creates a price comparison between different services. Clarifying this early is more useful than negotiating a discount on a package nobody has defined precisely.

      Separate the initial audit from recurring delivery

      An initial audit establishes the starting point: the pages you have, overlapping search intents, technical obstacles and the visitor's path to an enquiry. Recurring work uses that evidence to choose and implement the next improvements. Receiving a long report is not the same as having its recommendations deployed.

      Ask whether the first month covers diagnosis, implementation or both. Request an example of the final output: prioritised URLs, the reason for each change, an owner, an effort estimate and a verification method. If the audit finds a template issue in your ecommerce platform, identify whether the agency fixes it or hands it to your developer.

      The phrase “technical optimisation included” is too broad. It may mean a recommendations document, or it may include code changes, testing and deployment. Either arrangement can work. They require different budgets and different commitments from your team, so the distinction belongs in the proposal.

        Define the recurring scope

        A sensible monthly scope has a stable operating process and flexible priorities. The process includes reviewing evidence, choosing the most important obstacle, implementing agreed changes and checking the result. Flexibility matters because a new indexing problem or change in your commercial offering can become more important than an article planned weeks earlier.

        For content work, distinguish a new article from an improved service page, category revision or consolidation of overlapping pages. Each task should name the search intent and the visitor's next step. Length alone does not turn an article into a useful sales asset.

        For technical work, specify where diagnosis ends and implementation begins. For internal linking, identify the source and destination pages. For reporting, include a change log. This makes it possible to interpret movement alongside actual events on the site, instead of reacting to an isolated chart.

          A practical proposal comparison matrix

          Mark each criterion as explicitly included, separately priced, owned by your team or unanswered. Do not turn the labels into a supposedly scientific score. First resolve any critical task that has no owner. An impressive overall score cannot compensate for the absence of someone able to publish the work.

          Complete this matrix with the provider. “Is everything included?” invites a broad answer. “Who fixes the canonical tag in our category template and verifies the deployment?” reveals the operating model. Small projects can have short answers, but responsibility should still be unambiguous.

          • Business objective: are the priority products, market and definition of a useful enquiry explicit?
          • Diagnosis: will you receive prioritised issues with explanations?
          • Implementation: who changes the CMS, code, copy and links?
          • Content: who supplies expertise, checks facts and publishes?
          • Verification: who checks the public page, mobile experience and contact journey?
          • Measurement: are visits, enquiries and sales-qualified opportunities separate?
          • Coordination: who decides which work moves when a new priority appears?
          • Handover: can you see the changes made and access your own data?

          Compare the cost of a deliverable plan

          Include development, subject-matter review, localisation and internal coordination when comparing costs. A cost omitted from the agency's invoice often moves to your team. It does not disappear.

          Consider an illustrative example with invented figures. Proposal A costs EUR 700 per month and requires ten internal hours. Proposal B costs EUR 1,100 and requires two coordination hours. At an assumed internal planning rate of EUR 50 per hour, both represent EUR 1,200 of combined effort. These numbers are not NUMEDIA prices, market benchmarks or a forecast of return. They simply demonstrate why the smallest invoice may not represent the lowest total commitment.

          Capacity matters as much as arithmetic. If developers are unavailable for three months, template recommendations remain a backlog. Direct implementation or a smaller initial project may be a better fit. A recurring package does not solve a delivery bottleneck unless the engagement includes someone able to remove it.

            What to expect in the first 90 days

            The first month should establish a baseline and ownership. Select a small group of commercially important pages, check measurement and address the highest-priority obstacles. Fewer new articles and more useful fixes can be the right result if visitors were previously reaching a broken enquiry journey.

            The second month should demonstrate a repeatable process. Every completed task needs a public URL or other reviewable output, a description of the change and a verification record. For new content, check that its purpose differs from existing pages. For technical changes, confirm that important neighbouring journeys still work.

            Use the third month to review direction, not demand a guaranteed payback. Is delivery consistent? Is sales receiving appropriate enquiries? Is there enough evidence to continue the same priority? With a small number of leads, the honest conclusion may be that business impact cannot yet be distinguished from ordinary variation.

            This operating review should also test the assumptions in the original brief. Perhaps the selected service has a longer decision cycle than expected, or your team cannot provide the technical material required for credible content. Adjusting the plan in response is more useful than preserving a quota just because it appeared in the proposal.

              Reporting that supports decisions

              Separate a monthly report into completed work, observed changes and recommended decisions. The first section should contain tasks and URLs. The second should state data sources, dates and limitations. The third should explain next month's priorities and the reasoning behind them.

              Search Console describes performance in Google Search, including clicks, impressions and queries. It is not a record of closed deals. Business evaluation requires enquiry records and feedback from sales. Even then, distinguish the recorded source of an enquiry from proof that a particular article caused a purchase.

              When comparing periods, consider holidays, seasonality, offer changes and measurement changes. Do not add a domain property's results to those of subdomains already included in that property. A duplicated total is not an improvement in performance.

              A useful report may explicitly say that a question remains unanswered. For example, a new page may have started receiving impressions while enquiry volume is still too low to assess. That is more informative than assigning revenue to content without a defensible connection.

                Warning signs when choosing an agency

                Google's guidance on hiring an SEO advises checking references, communication and the reasoning behind recommendations. It also warns against guarantees of first place. No provider can sell you control over organic rankings.

                Ask how external links are obtained. Google's spam policies cover manipulative link practices. Do not evaluate a proposal solely by the number of links promised: ask about their origin, editorial purpose and risks. Apply similar scrutiny to plans for large quantities of near-identical pages with little additional value.

                A less obvious warning sign is a report without completed work. Attractive charts can conceal a backlog that nobody is implementing. Another is responsibility repeatedly moving between teams. Content waits for the client, development waits for the agency and reporting waits for data. A sound process surfaces those dependencies before work starts.

                  When a monthly retainer is the wrong choice

                  A limited project may be better if you have one clear technical issue and adequate content for your current offering. If the offer and audience are unresolved, work on those first. If nobody can approve specialist claims, appoint an owner. An SEO provider cannot replace missing business decisions.

                  Recurring work makes sense when the need repeats: multiple services, a changing catalogue, several markets or ongoing improvements to sales pages. Even then, identical article quotas every month are not essential. The scope should follow the most important constraints and opportunities.

                  For AI visibility, ask for a separate objective and measurement approach. Specialist GEO explanations belong in a focused resource, not an undefined add-on promising optimisation for every AI system. The proposal should make clear which work supports conventional search and which additionally addresses generative answers.

                    A brief for your next agency discussion

                    Bring three priority services, their current pages and anonymised examples of useful and unsuitable enquiries. Ask the provider to describe the first month on a single page. This quickly reveals whether the proposed work reflects your business.

                    NUMEDIA can use this brief as the starting point for a scope discussion. Share your website, target market and main service or product group. The purpose is to identify a workable engagement and a path to relevant enquiries, with clear responsibilities and realistic measurement.

                    • Our commercial objective and priority market are: …
                    • We recognise a useful enquiry by: …
                    • The first pages we will improve are: …
                    • The agency delivers: …; our team provides: …
                    • We verify completed work through: …
                    • The measurement and delivery constraints are: …
                    • We choose the next priority using: …

                    Sources and methodology

                    1. Do you need an SEO? (Google Search Central, accessed 2026-11-02)
                    2. Spam policies for Google web search (Google Search Central, accessed 2026-11-02)
                    3. Performance report: Search results (Google Search Console Help, accessed 2026-11-02)

                    Frequently asked questions

                    Is the lowest monthly fee the best choice?

                    Compare the full deliverable scope, including development and internal effort. A lower agency invoice can move work to your team.

                    Should every month include a new article?

                    Not necessarily. Prioritise the work that addresses a meaningful obstacle or commercial need, including improving existing pages.

                    Can an agency guarantee first place?

                    No. Google warns against ranking guarantees. Ask for a realistic plan, implementation evidence and measurement limitations.